Posted 30th September 2008 | 2 Comments
Time for reflection at New Street
The new light concourse will increase circulation capacity.
THE design of a £406m makeover for Birmingham New Street station has finally been settled – with the new structure clad in a reflective surface that will change as the day goes by. Already some Brummies have dubbed it ‘the silver armadillo’.
As the new design by Spanish architect Alejandro Zaera-Polo was unveiled, Network Rail’s London North Western route director Peter Strachan dismissed suggestions that new deep-level tunnels were planned to give extra capacity for north east/south west CrossCountry and Cross City trains.
“There is absolutely no intention of providing deep level tunnels,” he told a press conference, stressing that the aim of the project, now dubbed ‘New Street – New Start, the Birmingham Gateway Project’, was to increase passenger flow and pedestrian capacity.
Mr Strachan said the existing platforms would also get “a complete refresh”. They would be made “brighter, more sparkling to match the image above,” with 42 extra escalators and 14 more lifts linking them with the new concourse.
Individual platforms at New Street had to be closed 20 times last year due to overcrowding, according to Net-work Rail.
When Mr Strachan listed the funding agreed for the project – £168m from Birmingham City Council, £128m from Network Rail, £100m from Advantage West Midlands (the regional development agency) and £10m from Centro (the West Midlands Passenger Transport Executive), all adding up to just £406 million – there was no mention of any further investment from the private sector, even though the joint press release issued by all the sponsoring organisations referred to “the £600 million Gateway project”.
The proposed ‘twin towers’ commercial development on the south-west side of the station has also disappeared from the latest designs. Peter Strachan said the towers remained part of the overall plan, but architect Alejandro Zaera-Polo said they would be dealt with in a second phase.
Nor were there any signs or glossy images – as there had been on previous artists’ impressions – of any West Midlands Metro trams running by New Street station.
Birmingham City Council leader Mike Whitby ducked questions about extending the Metro from Snow Hill station to serve New Street – failing to mention that Transport Secretary Ruth Kelly withdrew funding for the planned Metro extensions earlier this year after West Midlands councils failed to agree on a road pricing scheme to fund public transport improvements, including extensions to the Metro.
AWM chief executive Mick Laverty said his agency’s £100 million contribution to the station redevelopment was the biggest investment in any project by any regional development body in Britain.
It reflected AWM’s belief that the project would bring £2 billion of benefits to the West Midlands’ regional economy, create 10,000 new jobs in central Birmingham “and be an iconic gateway to the Birmingham city region”.
Peter Strachan said the start of work was planned for next year, but confirmed detailed planning permission had still to be obtained. He said the plan was to open “a significant part of the new concourse” in 2012, with the whole scheme completed in 2014 (although this had become 2015 in a live interview on BBC News later).
The station design has been awarded to Foreign Office Architects and its principal partner Alejandro Zaera-Polo. His firm beat off 47 rivals, including many of the world’s top practices, to win a competition judged by a panel headed by Sir Bernard Zissman, a former Lord Mayor of Birmingham.
The judges had to consider 117 objectives and features in the design brief to satisfy the project’s financial sponsors.
Mr Zaera-Polo said Birmingham had become a model for urban regeneration, and his firm wanted to reflect the city in the design for New Street station. “So we started working with reflections,” he said.
The new exterior of the station will use “curved linear geometry” and be clad in a surface that “will change as the day goes by”, by reflecting the light at the different times of day, he explained.
“We want to make a new public square in the city centre, which will have open, cathedral-like space so people can see the growing skyline of the future Birmingham.”
Birmingham City Council leader Mike Whitby said the present New Street station had been developed 40 years ago to handle 16 million passengers a year. “At present it is coping with 33 to 34 million passengers and creaking at the seams,” he said, “but the new project will give capacity for up to 52 million passengers.”
Councillor Whitby said he believed the station redevelopment “will be an internationally-recognised landmark... and enhance our reputation as a truly world class city.”
Mr Zaera-Polo’s concept designs will now be developed by an integrated team led by Network Rail which will include Foreign Office Architects, WS Atkins as lead consultant and Mace as delivery partner.
Reader Comments:
Views expressed in submitted comments are that of the author, and not necessarily shared by Railnews.
H. T. Harvey, Birmingham, UK
New St/Gateway
Back to the 1960s'
Are Network Rail and all the rail pres being suckered by the slick retailproperty developers. The £600million cost of Gateway will supply 42 new escalators and a few lifts but NO REAL RAIL CAPACITY improvement. Even worse the private sector MAY pay £100million but the the public sector pays £500 to £600million.
The station is incapable of expansion or relief with 4 tracks in and 4 tracks out and al of these subject to severe speed restrictions that extend for substantial distances on each side of the station.
Platfor 13 has been removed by the ORR
Network rails answer is to increase train lengths. This may help but II already there are problems looming with LM trains being increased to 8 coach and Platforms will not hold 2x 8coach.
Virgins Pendolinos are too be increased to 11 cars and peak frequency increased. X Country will no doubt want to double up some of their trains.
ALL this would be great news but remember as longer train takes longer to clear track circuits and these trains will be travelling very slowly. All in all this is likely to reduce station capacity at peak times.
Then there is the 'cathedral like glass fronted wating room' spin for a airport style departure lounge/retail development.
This is of course the real hidden agenda behind Gateway IT IS NAUGHT BUT A RETAIL DEVELOPMENT parasite on captive rail passengers - 52 million passengers the 'footfall' will demand massive rents.
Virgin spokesmen said they would bid for London airports saying passengers wanted to to get straight on the plane and not wait in a departure lounge. Yet the Gateway gang are proposing to foist this on Birmingham passengers all 50million of them. Net Rail say passengers will wait in the Glass fronted atrium for their trains.So passsengers wishing to change trains will take longer to change and what about commuters. Such a system will further increase platform times for trains and reduce train capacity. But boy oh boy it will be a boon to the shops in the glass fronted waiting room so who cares about the rail passenger.
Then theirs HS2 New St cannot accomodate HS2 traffic. In this event Birmingham will be connected to HS2 via changing trains at International or be at the end of a 100mph branch line hardly sutable for the UKs second city and certainly defeating the object of HS2.
No Gateway is a farce. New St should be downgraded to a city centre suburban station of about 4 to 6 platforms and a new station built in Eastside with proper interchange between all ground transport systems. AND directly connected to HS2 north and south services with the room for expansion.
Once more the rail system/passenger is being made to suffer for retail development - shades of the 1960s.
The credit crunch could be a blessing in disguise and put the skids under this white elephant lets see some real rail development.
don brad, birmingham
Tragic that the project is really millions on a facelift. New Street isn't especially crowded. Compare with mainline stations in London